New York Magazine

Meta’s massive $17.1 billion settlement over social media’s alleged harm to teenagers is being called Big Tech’s tobacco moment, but its promised safety reforms may fall short.
New York Magazine: Meta’s Reckoning
Author: John Herrman
Three years ago, dozens of states jointly sued Meta, alleging it had designed its technology “to entice, engage, and ultimately ensnare” young users. At stake, the lawsuit said, was no less than the “mental and physical health of our nation’s youth.”
In 2023, the legal theory of the lawsuit — that consumers, and especially young people, need protection from Meta’s platforms much in the way they need protection from tobacco products — was unusual. Now, it lines up with the popular mood about social media and has become something rare in America: a bipartisan rallying cry. Negotiations about screen time (with your kids and with yourself) are now a burden of modern life. Schools across the country are trying to enforce “bell to bell” phone bans. In 2010, The Social Network posed the question, “Is this Facebook guy maybe sort of bad?” This year, The Social Reckoning will answer, “Yeah, he really is!” Whatever else you think our biggest political and social problems are, there is a good chance you think your phone, and the apps on it, has something to do with them.
In August, when Meta reached a massive settlement with 47 states, agreeing to pay up to $17.1 billion, it was considered social media’s big-tobacco moment. An industry in need of reform, intervention, and perhaps even retribution was getting its due. The settlement required the company to make changes to its products for young users: an age-verification system; parent-controlled time limits; nighttime-usage restrictions. There would be new notification controls and “productive pauses” for under-18s. Options for “non-algorithmic” feeds, without personalized suggestions, would be added to teen accounts.
But there are reasons to be skeptical this will all lead to rapid, major change. Meta’s concessions for under-18 users are limited in scope and will almost certainly be implemented in ways that make them less effective than they sound. By default, usage time limits, curfews, hidden like counts, and school-hour notification mutes will be turned on. But all can be overridden by parents: In the end, they will remain responsible for managing their children’s relationship to social media. Age-verification systems come with privacy trade-offs and are difficult to implement. In Australia, which enacted an under-16 social-media ban late last year, the effects were underwhelming: The government said in March an estimated two-thirds of “children under 16 retained accounts on age-restricted platforms.”
Parts of the settlement are also contingent on the actions of Meta’s competitors — including YouTube and TikTok, which are facing numerous lawsuits of their own. Meta will release around $5 billion more to plaintiffs only if its competitors commit to making similar changes and paying billions to the states as well. Without that, teens prevented from scrolling on Instagram might simply move to TikTok, YouTube, or Snapchat, which Meta argues would make its changes ineffective.
Rather than a dramatic reset, the post-settlement reality marks the beginning of a slog. The vast majority of Meta’s domestic users will remain glued to their feeds. And Meta can expect to keep being targeted for the addictive services that drive its profits. “There are thousands of individual lawsuits” to come, says James Grimmelmann, a professor of digital and information law at Cornell University. He predicts a future of legal “paper cuts” for the company. Meta’s willingness to settle and obvious eagerness to avoid additional public spectacle could even inspire more people to sue.
As the legal battles continue, the company’s reputation will be dragged further down. The litigation to date against Meta — which focused on personal injury and consumer protection rather than the platforms’ well-shielded speech and hosting rights — have produced damning documents and testimony that have embarrassed the social-media giant. “The product is very good at connecting people with interests, and if your interest is little girls, it will be really good at connecting you with little girls,” a former Meta executive told a court in New Mexico. In Los Angeles, jurors were shown internal documents in which a Meta employee argued, “If we wanna win big with teens, we must bring them in as tweens.” The states presented in their lawsuit an internal study from Meta called “Long Term Retention: The Young Ones Are the Best Ones” and shared a 2016 email listing “teen time spent” as a goal for Instagram.
For now, Meta still has control over its business, and $17.1 billion doesn’t mean much to a company that made more than $60 billion in profit last year. But the company has lost control of its story. Social media has become a friendless technology. It has been unable — despite Zuckerberg’s public efforts to ingratiate himself with Trump in 2024 and 2025 — to take advantage of the current administration’s tech-focused deregulatory spree. Crypto companies and prediction markets, in seeming thanks for their donations during election cycles or because of their connections to the White House, are being protected from state regulators by the federal government. In contrast, state and federal lawmakers are pushing ahead with social-media legislation with broad support. The Kids Online Safety Act, which would impose on social-media companies a “duty of care” for minors on their platforms, is already working its way through Congress, and much of the 2028 field will be running on similar ideas. Meta’s legal and political predicament will feel familiar to anyone who spends time on one of its platform’s algorithmic feeds. In front of Zuckerberg lies an infinite scroll of distractions — each one slightly different, yet all of them basically the same — systematically targeted to extract as much value from him as possible.
Facebook, the company, narrated the rise of mainstream social media as a liberating phenomenon, a project to “connect the world,” freely and naturally deploying the language of community, civic responsibility, and opportunity, both individual and collective. For the past decade, its official story has been defensive and legalistic as it responds to near-constant allegations of being complicit in social-media-fueled atrocities, violating users’ privacy, poisoning electoral politics, and poisoning childhood itself.
It’s no wonder Zuckerberg wants to pry some of his attention from social media, too. Earlier in August, before the settlement figure became public, Zuckerberg published a lengthy manifesto, titled “ The Future Is for Everyone,” to make a “positive” case for artificial intelligence, toward which his company is committing hundreds of billions of dollars. Zuckerberg positions his essay as a counterpoint to widespread narratives of AI doom and despair. It’s also, clearly, a chance to talk about something else and escape from the dreary present into a bright rhetorical future. Social media appears only once, as an aside, in the essay’s more than 6,500 words.
But Meta’s past haunts the document in subtler ways. In Meta’s AI future, Zuckerberg envisions deploying, for every user, an “agent” that “understands you, your goals, and everything you care about.” For all the fresh language of “superintelligence” and “alignment,” this, too, may sound familiar. Meta can’t leave its tainted products behind or shed their liabilities. It might even try to build them again.
Credits: TCA, LLC.